Direct and indirect punishment among strangers in the field

Direct and indirect punishment among strangers in the field

DSpace/Manakin Repository

Direct and indirect punishment among strangers in the field

Show simple item record

dc.contributor Thomas Lauer;University of Cologne;Aufbewahrungseinrichtung (Hosting Institution)
dc.coverage.spatial Deutschland / DE en_US
dc.date.accessioned 2019-07-02T12:58:35Z
dc.date.available 2019-07-02T12:58:35Z
dc.date.issued 2019-07-02
dc.identifier.uri http://doi.org/10.7802/1908
dc.description Many interactions in modern human societies are among strangers. Explaining cooperation in such interactions is challenging. The two most prominent explanations critically depend on individuals’ willingness to punish defectors: In models of direct punishment,individuals punish antisocial behavior at a personal cost, whereas in models of indirect reciprocity, they punish indirectly by withholding rewards. We investigate these competing explanations in a field experiment with real-life interactions among strangers. We find clear evidence of both direct and indirect punishment. Direct punishment is not rewarded by strangers and, in line with models of indirect reciprocity, is crowded out by indirect punishment opportunities. The existence of direct and indirect punishment in daily life indicates the importance of both means for understanding the evolution of cooperation. en_US
dc.rights CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 en_US
dc.subject.other Volkswirtschaftslehre en_US
dc.title Direct and indirect punishment among strangers in the field en_US
dbk.publication ;www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.1413170111
dbk.availability Eingeschränkter Zugang en_US
dbk.publicationyear 2014 en_US
dbk.primaryresearcher Loukas Balafoutas;University of Innsbruck
dbk.primaryresearcher Nikos Nikiforakis;New York University Abu Dhabi
dbk.primaryresearcher Bettina Rockenbach;University of Cologne
intern.checklist {"intern_checklist":"","so_erhebungsinstrument_fragebogen_typ":"n.a.","tf_erhebungsinstrument_fragebogen_originaldateiname":"","tf_erhebungsinstrument_codebuch_originaldateiname":"","tf_erhebungsinstrument_projecktbericht_originaldateiname":"","tf_erhebungsinstrument_methodenbericht_originaldateiname":"","ta_erhebungsinstrument_kommentar":"","cb_datendateien_allgemein_passen_Daten_zum_Projekt":"on","cb_datendateien_allgemein_faelle_vorhanden":"on","cb_datendateien_allgemein_variablen_vollstaendig":"on","cb_datendateien_speziell_gewichte_korrekt":"n.a.","cb_datendateien_speziell_variablenlabels_vorhanden":"n.a.","cb_datendateien_speziell_wertelabels_vorhanden":"n.a.","cb_datendateien_plausibilitaetpruefung_geschlecht":"n.a.","cb_datendateien_plausibilitaetpruefung_alter":"n.a.","cb_datendateien_plausibilitaetpruefung_anzahl_haushalt":"n.a.","cb_datendateien_plausibilitaetpruefung_einkomensverteilung":"n.a.","cb_datendateien_plausibilitaetpruefung_filterfuehrung_korrekt":"n.a.","cb_datendateien_datenschutz_datenerhebung":"on","cb_datendateien_datenschutz_regionale_einheiten":"n.a.","cb_datendateien_datenschutz_berufsklassifikation":"n.a.","ta_datendateien_datenschutz_kommentar":"","ta_datendateien_journaldaten_kommentar":"","tf_fazit_dateinamen":"","tf_fazit_gefunden_in_dateinamen":"","cb_fazit_daten_nachnutzbar":"on","cb_fazit_daten_vertriebsfaehig":"on","cb_fazit_stata":"on","cb_fazit_andere":"on","ta_fazit_kommentar":"","tf_bearbeiter":"Cziesla","submit_jump_0.5":"Checklist"} en_US
dbk.universe 447 en_US
dbk.datacollectionmethod Beobachtung en_US
dbk.datacollectionmethod Interview en_US
dbk.primaryresearcher.person Loukas Balafoutas en_US
dbk.primaryresearcher.person Nikos Nikiforakis en_US
dbk.primaryresearcher.person Bettina Rockenbach en_US
dbk.primaryresearcher.institution University of Innsbruck en_US
dbk.primaryresearcher.institution New York University Abu Dhabi en_US
dbk.primaryresearcher.institution University of Cologne en_US
dbk.availability.de Eingeschränkter Zugang de_DE
dbk.availability.en Restricted Access en_US
dc.coverageSpatial.de Deutschland / DE de_DE
dc.coverageSpatial.en Germany / DE en_US
dc.subjectOther.de Volkswirtschaftslehre de_DE
dc.subjectOther.en Political Economy en_US
dbk.datacollectionmethod.de Interview de_DE
dbk.datacollectionmethod.de Beobachtung de_DE
dbk.datacollectionmethod.en Interview en_US
dbk.datacollectionmethod.en Observation en_US


Files in this submission

Files Size Format Download Option Description
DIPF_All_data_experiment.xlsx 91.13Kb Microsoft Excel 2007 Download {"dbk_file_desc":"Data set","dbk_version_series_desc":"","dbk_version_number_desc":"","dbk_resourcetype_series_desc":"spreadsheet","dbk_resourcetype_number_desc":"Datensatz","dc_language_iso_desc":"","dbk_dataset_variable_desc":"","dbk_dataset_item_series_desc":"","dbk_dataset_item_number_desc":"","dbk_software_desc":"","dbk_alternativeid_desc":"","dbk_relatedid_series_desc":"","dbk_relatedid_number_desc":"","description":""}
File checksum: MD5:6075b9a260307c7e4445ae276d0f56bc
DIPF_do_file_experiment.do 1.659Kb text/x-stata-syntax Download {"dbk_file_desc":"STATA do file","dbk_version_series_desc":"","dbk_version_number_desc":"","dbk_resourcetype_series_desc":"Stata do file","dbk_resourcetype_number_desc":"Software","dc_language_iso_desc":"","dbk_dataset_variable_desc":"","dbk_dataset_item_series_desc":"","dbk_dataset_item_number_desc":"","dbk_software_desc":"","dbk_alternativeid_desc":"","dbk_relatedid_series_desc":"","dbk_relatedid_number_desc":"","description":""}
File checksum: MD5:1b937d429f985e65a2c9034938337d86
DIPF_do_file_surveys.do 380bytes text/x-stata-syntax Download {"dbk_file_desc":"STATA do file","dbk_version_series_desc":"","dbk_version_number_desc":"","dbk_resourcetype_series_desc":"Stata do file","dbk_resourcetype_number_desc":"Software","dc_language_iso_desc":"","dbk_dataset_variable_desc":"","dbk_dataset_item_series_desc":"","dbk_dataset_item_number_desc":"","dbk_software_desc":"","dbk_alternativeid_desc":"","dbk_relatedid_series_desc":"","dbk_relatedid_number_desc":"","description":""}
File checksum: MD5:c6dd196aa8fcf0f025d8c8507cb50a98
DIPF_survey_data.dta 14.44Kb application/x-stata Download {"dbk_file_desc":"STATA data file","dbk_version_series_desc":"","dbk_version_number_desc":"","dbk_resourcetype_series_desc":"Stata data file","dbk_resourcetype_number_desc":"Datensatz","dc_language_iso_desc":"","dbk_dataset_variable_desc":"","dbk_dataset_item_series_desc":"","dbk_dataset_item_number_desc":"","dbk_software_desc":"","dbk_alternativeid_desc":"","dbk_relatedid_series_desc":"","dbk_relatedid_number_desc":"","description":""}
File checksum: MD5:63ee9adbe2043e3944a41f7f6c5eb502
DIPF_Skript_Schauspieler.pdf 146.8Kb PDF Download {"dbk_file_desc":"script for actors","dbk_version_series_desc":"","dbk_version_number_desc":"","dbk_resourcetype_series_desc":"script / instructions","dbk_resourcetype_number_desc":"Text","dc_language_iso_desc":"","dbk_dataset_variable_desc":"","dbk_dataset_item_series_desc":"","dbk_dataset_item_number_desc":"","dbk_software_desc":"","dbk_alternativeid_desc":"","dbk_relatedid_series_desc":"","dbk_relatedid_number_desc":"","description":""}
File checksum: MD5:7a22b25c973c69e0b4ffdea15d629ebd

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

Show simple item record

Search DSpace


Advanced Search

Browse

My datorium